Malicious Prosecution
Have you been victim to malicious prosection? You may be able to claim against the police.
What is Malicious Prosecution?
Malicious prosecution is a tort (civil wrong) that allows someone to bring a claim to challenge a criminal prosecution against them.
A claimant must prove four distinct elements:
- They have been prosecuted by the defendant
- The prosecution was determined in their favour
- The prosecution was instigated without reasonable and probably cause
- The prosecution was instigated maliciously
In practice, the first two of these elements are rarely an issue. The main battlegrounds are typically the last two points: reasonable and probable cause, and malice.
Reasonable and Probable Cause
In the case of Herniman v Smith [1938] AC 305, reasonable and probable cause is defined as:
“An honest belief in the guilt of the accused based upon a full conviction, founded upon reasonable grounds, of the existence of circumstances which, assuming them to be true, would reasonably lead any ordinary prudent and cautious man, placed in the position of the accuser, to the conclusion that the person charged was probably guilty of the crime imputed.”
In simple terms, it means:
- The prosecutor must honestly believe you committed the offence, and
- That belief must be based on reasonable grounds – facts or circumstances that would lead a sensible person to also believe you were guilty.
The law does not require the prosecutor to have enough evidence to guarantee a conviction. It is enough that there was sufficient evidence to bring a charge.
Malice
Malice is a separate requirement. The question is solely subjective: what was the motive?
An improper motive “must be the driving force behind the prosecution” (Williamson v Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago [2014] UKPC 29).
An improper motive is anything other than the pursuit of justice.
Malice can be inferred from the absence of reasonable and probable cause, but a jury is not obliged to do so. In other words, even if a charge is laid without reasonable and probably cause, if it is laid in good faith and with the intention of pursuing justice, the claim will not be made out.
In practice, these cases can be extremely difficult unless there is clear evidence (a “smoking gun”) that the charge was motivated by malice, or that the case was completely baseless.
CALL US
Speak To An Expert Now
Give us a call now to get an initial assessment and find out how we can help you.
Make A Claim for Malicious Prosecution
We pride ourselves on helping our clients with the issues that matter most. That includes making sure the police are held accountable if they’ve treated you unfairly.
Our expert police claim solicitors are here to help you. We can offer you:
- No win no fee service
- We cover England & Wales
- Clear, easy-to-understand advice throughout the whole process
Call us on 01925 351 350 to get started with your claim.
Covering England & Wales
